In Very Grudging Praise Of…
Posted on Sunday, December 20th, 2009 in: Misc.
… Battlestar Galactica.
Now!
This entry will hopefully be brief, because I spent many, many months arguing with my editor about the merits or otherwise of the TV-remake of Battlestar Galactica that has graced screens for the last few years. My position being that it was rubbish; his position being that it was the greatest thing ever made. My conviction that it was rubbish was, I fully admit, based on dubious information. I’d seen some of the original series, which was, let’s face it, not exactly Shakespeare Does Robots, and I’d seen bits of the new series, which seemed to involve more sombre staring into the vacant beyond and more sweaty vests than I’d thought one little screen could ever contain. And my god the vests are sweaty, I mean, let’s not beat about the bush here, more artily-disshevelled-gleaming-sexy-people-having-a-horrid-time-on-the-edge-of-breaking you’re unlikely to ever meet.
But…
… since then, Battlestar Galactica has come to my local library…
… and thence to my DVD player…
… and so, after all this, I grudgingly and with all the grace of a wounded buffalo, reform my position. I would still argue that perhaps it takes itself a little bit too seriously… ‘light relief’ are not words you’re likely to run across in the course of any of Battlestar Galactica’s series… but on the other hand, in the absence of light relief, it does an absolutely brilliant job of retaining ‘crushing tension’ right up to the very, very end, as humanity, and along the way, the other lot too, battle against each other, themselves, the possibility of exctinction, death, misery, and all the symptoms of all the above on the way. When there’s action, it’s utterly thrilling; when there’s betrayal, it’s soul-wrenching; when there’s politics, its savage; when religion, it’s fanatical.
And it says a lot about Battlestar Galactica that my one lingering caveat now that the series has run its course, is, naturally, a caveat about the nature of god. But, if you wish to find out why this is my last narrative concern, you’ll just have to watch it, won’t you?
1 Comment so far - click here to join in
Well, I certainly wouldn’t argue that BG a bit…po-faced at times, and does take itsself a little too seriously at times, but the overall themes and the politics, combined with the human issues, and a weird machine religion thrown in for good measure has made BG a truly compelling series, showing a level of sophistication largely missing from TV sci-fi. A great ensemble cast also helps, as I mentioned in the West Wing blog; it’s something that America just seems to do so well, and they’re not afraid to use actors from all over the world, either, the number of Brits in American TV astonishes me sometimes, I’ve watched some series for ages before belatedly discovering that the actress with the broad Brooklyn accent is actually English, or the ‘Irish’ actress in another actually comes from Middlesex (Gabriellle Anwar in Burn Notice).
I love US TV series…
December 20, 2009